Saving Seacountry

Dugongs and turtles are vanishing from remote Cape York. Now, residents have a plan to bring them back.

In one direction the beach stretches towards a distant vanishing point, in the other, the dark shape of a headland hammers into the shallow sea.

Positioned within the shelter of the Great Barrier Reef and a day north of the nearest town, Elim seems a world removed from our own

The land rover rattles down the hill towards the beach, and the sea and sand lace together through the windscreen, delivering a blinding glare. Over 1500 kilometres from Brisbane, Queensland's capital city, Elim is about as remote as you can get before needing an off-roading rig.

The horizon here is consumed by the sea, with the beach and steep dunes a footnote. Trees appear turn away from the ocean, with tall paperbarks and crouching shrubs arched inland by trade winds that curl into the bay for months at a time.

Here, running alongside the ocean sits Eddie's camp. The scattering of tents and trucks blends into the bushscape with surprising ease. Wildlife seems unbothered by the arrangement. Insects walk up the gums in marching lines, sea eagles sweep through the canopy, and mudskippers lurk among the mangroves that edge along Elim’s white sands.

One would expect this zeal to extend beyond the land, out into the bay –but instead, the ocean here is quiet. Old stories tell of behemoth sea turtles cruising these waters, with shells large enough for people to ride them like surfboards. Dugongs, the sea cows, once lay below the surface in vast herds, hidden from humans except for when they came up to breathe their heavy sighs of salty air. Today, Elim’s breath-taking dugongs and gracious turtles are rarely seen. I have come to speak with one of the few people who can tell me why. 

Ivan Deemal has lived alongside this seascape for over a decade, managing his family's traditional land. Eddie’s camp is the main access point for Elim beach, carrying the name of Ivan's father, a man determined to share his idyllic country with visitors. 

“I’m carrying on his legacy, he always wanted to set up a campground at some stage, and so he did that about in the '70s.” 

To say Ivan’s family have been living at Elim for a long time is a massive understatement. The Thiithaarr-warra people arrived in the area sometime in the past 50,000 years . Their culture and language are among the oldest on Earth. 

It’s a history told through stories that weave the iconic landscape into ancient times, stories that often lead back to the sea. Today, that focus on the ocean continues to flow through Elim’s lore and into conversations about the future. When I speak with Ivan about this future, the conversation returns to stories of the adored turtle and dugong. 

“My Dad always says that there used to be a lot of turtles in this area. That the turtles were always popping up, they were basically always there.” 

Ivan conjures up the older times with stories of his forefathers wandering the land, hunting in tune with the seasonal cycles of mullet, turtle, and dugong; taking when there was plenty and leaving species alone in the quieter months.

Since prehistory, the land here has remained relatively unchanged: dramatic cliff faces coloured by rainbow sands and sunsets that linger for hours.

That unchanging nature doesn’t extend to Elim’s sea life.

As human influence over the reef has ramped up in recent decades, Elim’s previously wildlife has taken a hit and locals have noticed the change. 

"In my younger days, I remember that you’d go out there with a boat, and the turtle would pop up". Ivan waves towards the peaceful bay as he speaks: "Out there, like it was feeding on the grasses. And you’d see a dugong every now and then, but not so much these days."

Climate change is battering the Great Barrier Reef, with impacts ranging from coral bleaching to species loss. This deterioration is being heavily felt in environments like Elim's mangrove swamps and seagrass meadows, along with the wildlife that frequent these habitats.

As climate change hits the reef, the low-lying islands where turtles lay their eggs are vanishing. Dugongs face a similar plight, with increased water temperatures uprooting the seagrass they feed on. 

Elim's traditional owners depend on the continued health of this landscape. Hopevale is an indigenous community that sits 30 kilometres inland of Elim, and its 1500 residents rely on the beach for fishing. These waters are a food source for seven clans, and dugong and turtles are the best catch. A single dugong can provide enough meat to feed an entire family and host a barbecue. Turtles are more plentiful and easier to catch, and their meat keeps for longer. 

 Along Elim’s shore, three-pronged spears lean against the towering gum trees. Boats are carried from the community on ramshackle trailers and pushed off into the bay, their skippers searching for the remaining turtles and dugong. This relationship with sea-country relies on the continued abundance of turtles and dugong. But climate change imperils these lifestyles.

The overarching issues of climate change, overexploitation and environmental collapse can be inaccessible to those fishing Elim’s beaches: Australia’s governance takes place out of sight, tens of thousands of kilometres away, and big decisions regarding these problems seem removed from their world. So Guugu Yimithirr elders decided to make a change. 

brown turtle in body of water

Photo by David Troeger on Unsplash

Photo by David Troeger on Unsplash

two gray seal underwater

Photo by NOAA on Unsplash

Photo by NOAA on Unsplash

Elders envisaged a plan to preserve the vanishing turtle and dugong; one that their people could take part in -a localised, indigenous science approach. 

Ivan reiterates this vision to me. As our conversation continues, he passes me a bound stack of papers. The book is covered with children's drawings of dugongs, its pages loaded with tables, signatures, and guidelines. Running across the cover are the words: Turtle and Dugong - A Guugu Yimithirr Bama Wii. The title refers to the overarching name for the area's clans, Guugu Yimithirr. Bama Wii roughly translates to plan for the people. 

Sitting in the shade of Eddie's camp, history feels closer. A light breeze carries heat away and draws the smell of smoke in. Leaves ripple into shimmers of sound, a backing track that scores Ivan's words as he speaks of the science upon which hunting once relied. 

“In the old days, my father said that it [hunting] would only happen during the Christmas season, so about November to January. That’s when they did the hunting, and it was very rarely done at other times.” 

Reimplementing a short hunting season like that used in the past would help ease the strain on pressured turtles and dugong. Turtles are a migratory species and only frequent Elim's waters as visitors; Ivan suggests that turtles know when an area is dangerous, and the constant hunting at Elim has driven them away. Perhaps a break would draw in more animals, fostering a healthier catch when hunting.

Dugongs remain at Elim yearlong, raising their young during the cooler months. Guggu Yimithirr knowledge systems emphasised these cycles, and dugongs were only hunted during the months when babies were not present.

Recreating this balance would preserve local dugong populations. The rebirth of dugong numbers at Elim could allow the residents of Hopevale to visit the bay and see the gentle beasts perusing the clear waters once again - a hopeful idea. 

The second dilemma that the Bama Wii focuses on is how many animals should be taken from the beach each year. As the community has grown inland, hunting at Elim has followed suit

Ivan explains that in the past "there weren’t that many people, and the clans that were hunting were only small, less than 100 people, so they could survive on small catch”.

More hunting is taking place along Elim's shore than ever before, a worrying fact when contrasted with the precarious state of turtle and dugong populations. The Bama Wii suggests that the community train a ranger to watch over Elim, a guardian who could check catches and prevent overhunting. Special licenses for more take might be gifted to families for celebrations, like weddings.

image

Photo by Yohan Marion on Unsplash

Photo by Yohan Marion on Unsplash

Within the Bama Wii, drawings from Hopevale students illustrate how hunting methods have shifted. One artwork shows a hunter leaning out of a tin boat, spear searching the green water. At the boat's stern, an outboard motor idles, emblazoned with the words: 40 horsepower.  

In recent decades, the culture surrounding dugong and turtle hunting has shifted as new ideas and technology have reached Australia's far north. Modern hunting tools are a massive departure from those used in the past: motorised engines, radar, and spear guns are all new additions. As the cape has become more connected, hunting has become less demanding. For Elim's dugong and turtles, the increasingly casual nature of a once-revered and occasional practice has been harmful. 

The fast-paced nature of new technology used in hunting Elim's slow-moving animals is of great concern to Ivan. 

‘Hunting is now done with high-powered motors -there is no chance for a turtle or dugong.’

Under ideal sea conditions, a sea turtle can paddle at about 35 kilometres per hour. By contrast, a boat equipped with a 40 horsepower engine can hit speeds up to 50 kilometres per hour -easily outpacing the turtle. Ivan questions whether a turtle can have a fair chance under these conditions. 

 The Bama Wii provides a basic outline for reeling in the impacts of local hunting, but it cannot explore the inherent uncertainty in planning for Elim's future.

It is a local approach to environmental issues unfolding on a global scale. External pressures have destabilised the resources on which the Guugu Yimithirr nation relies. As turtles and dugongs have vanished from the area, hunting has become unbalanced; the science that grounds traditional practice has guided Elim's people in the past. Ivan says they must turn to this knowledge again to protect their country. 

The Bama Wii constantly reinforces that better education is the key to balancing hunting practices with the changing nature of Elim's wildlife. The local school may tie into these plans by passing on traditional knowledge to children: equipping them with a grounded vision of what marine life and richness could look like at sites such as Elim.

There is great value in turning to old wisdom when addressing uncertainty. Exchanging knowledge and drawing from different methods when solving problems helps form well-rounded solutions that are more likely to succeed. By adjusting their actions, the Guugu Yimithirr clans hope to preserve their sea country in the face of warming waters, rising tides, and changing times while also setting an example for the next generation of hunters and guardians. 

gray stones on seashore during daytime

Photo by Pedro Novales on Unsplash

Photo by Pedro Novales on Unsplash

The tide has rolled out again when Ivan and I finish talking; I pack away the microphone, and he slides the stack of Bama Wii back into their box.

A kingfisher gives a beady stare as I meander to the low tide mark to look for turtles: no sign today. Perhaps through a plan like the Bama Wii, more turtles and dugongs will frequent Elim. So, on days like this one, a wanderer might be able to gaze across the sharp reflections of the bay towards the inevitable headland and see a turtle's head bob up or a dugong take a breath: A return to the richness of Ivan's youth, of Guugu Yimithirr stories, and the Bama Wii vision.